Research PaperTelling different stories, making new realities: The ontological politics of ‘addiction’ biographies
Introduction
Personal narratives of addiction circulate widely in popular culture. Indeed the media has long been filled with such stories but they often rely on stereotypes and offer few clues about the variety of experiences people have and the many ways they cope and live rich, meaningful lives. Despite the dominance of addiction biographies in popular culture and in some therapeutic settings, relatively little research has explored the norms operating in these accounts and how they shape people’s experiences and identities. In this paper we build on the insights of the critical addiction literature to analyse biographies produced as part of a qualitative study of personal experiences of alcohol and other drug addiction in Australia. The biographies were reconstructed from in-depth interviews with 60 people who self-identified as having an addiction, dependence or habit, and published on a carefully curated, public website www.livesofsubstance.org. While accounts such as those we developed are often presumed to reflect faithfully ‘real-life’ experiences, we argue that they produce normative ideas about addiction, with implications for people whose drug use would attract this label. In making this argument we draw on the work of science and technology studies theorists Annemarie Mol (1999) and John Law (2004) to challenge the assumption that it is possible to uncover a pre-existing objective reality of addiction. These scholars argue that there is no stable, singular reality that precedes our attempts to know it. Rather, knowledge practices perform what Mol and Law call ‘ontological politics’. The concept of ontological politics theorises realities as neither given nor fixed, but shaped within specific practices. The key point of this insight is that we are active in making realities so which ones we make is a political question. In this article, we are concerned with how the practices of reconstructing personal narratives from interviews with people who identify as having an alcohol or other drug addiction, dependence or habit help to make addiction and those who see themselves as affected by it.
In a previous article (Pienaar et al., 2015) we analysed accounts of addiction in two major Australian alcohol and other drug-related websites, arguing that they shape as much as reflect addiction, also shaping individual experiences. We outlined the planned website mentioned above and briefly considered how it might challenge stereotypes and in so doing, help to remake addiction. Here we build on this work to explore in detail how the biographies we produced for the website intervene in the social production of addiction. Comparing conventional addiction biographies with our alternative biographies, we spell out the different accounts of addiction and the self they generate. In conducting this comparative analysis, the focus is on how the biographies we produced disrupt the classic addiction narratives of trauma, collapse and redemption that tend to dominate the media and public discourse (Fraser and valentine, 2008). By drawing attention to the agency of those usually depicted as lacking it, and positing agency as a relational achievement, our biographies challenge existing accounts of addiction as a disorder of individual compulsivity. Beyond this, they show how people cope, even thrive, with the kind of consumption that would attract an addiction diagnosis. This emphasis on challenging conventional addiction narratives is not an attempt to dismiss people’s struggles or suffering, but rather to draw attention to the ways in which narrating addiction as a disease of compulsivity may actually generate suffering by reinforcing stigma and discrimination.
In the next sections, we provide some background to the Australian alcohol and other drug treatment system, before reviewing the relevant critical social science literature that focusses on addiction (auto)biographies, identifying a need for further work in this area. We then outline our theoretical approach and methods. This is followed by an analysis of traditional addiction autobiographies where we identify their tendency to pathologise and stigmatise regular drug use. Against this backdrop, we then present a range of alternative biographical accounts, which together offer new ways of constituting addiction, or as we will argue, emerge from a different ‘ontological politics’ than currently operates in dominant accounts of addiction. We conclude by exploring the implications of providing these new narratives.
Section snippets
Background
Addiction is by no means a simple issue and the term itself is heavily contested. In Australia, the official term in medical and public health circles is ‘dependence’ (Ministerial Council on Drug Strategy, 2011) and in other contexts, terms such as ‘compulsive behaviour’ or ‘drug problem’ dominate. Treatment for alcohol and other drug dependence is delivered via a range of government funded services, including counselling, pharmacotherapy, residential treatment and withdrawal management (
Approach
To conduct our analysis, we draw on the concept of ‘ontological politics’ first coined by science and technology studies theorist Annemarie Mol (1999) and later elaborated by Mol’s close collaborator John Law, 2004, Law, 2009a. The term refers to an approach that treats materiality as constantly in the making, rather than given in nature and fixed. Underpinning the notion of ontological politics is the recognition that practices, including those associated with research, produce particular
Method
The qualitative research project on which this article is based was designed to gather personal accounts of drug use for presentation on a web-based resource on addiction experiences [www.livesofsubstance.org]. The project is a collaboration with Healthtalk Australia, an Australian research consortium that conducts qualitative research into personal experiences of health and illness. Healthtalk Australia collaborative projects use a research methodology developed by Oxford University’s Health
Narrating addiction as a disorder of compulsion
We begin with a classic addiction narrative taken from the US website, drugfree.org:
My name is Sofia and I am a recovering addict and alcoholic. I started using when I was 12 years old. What started out as drinking alcohol and smoking weed quickly escalated into regular use of narcotics, and by the age of 13 I was abusing cocaine and prescription pills on a regular basis […]
My life was out of control […] After an incident in which I threatened to commit suicide, I was forced into a long-term
Beyond pathology: Remaking addiction
A key decision informing the composition of our participant biographies relates to how each account opens.2 Consider, for example, the openings to the biographies of 43-year old Bill and 53-year old Helen:
Bill works part time in retail and enjoys spending time doing outdoor activities with his wife and two children. He goes camping and bush walking,
Suffering, trauma and drug use
One of the risks in critiquing addiction discourse as we attempt to do here is that it can appear to dismiss or minimise suffering and struggles. This, of course, is not our aim. Rather, in narrating lived experiences, we have sought to present these struggles and difficulties in the context of people’s lives. Doing so draws attention to the ways in which addiction is bound up with other social and political issues, such as marginalisation, poverty, violence, isolation, stigma and institutional
Articulating pleasures and benefits
While the biographies communicate the struggles and difficulties people face, they do so without eclipsing or discounting the pleasures and benefits of drug use. Consider, for example, this extract from 32-year old Dean’s biography:
Dean (32) began taking ice [methamphetamine] and GHB in his early twenties, primarily with sexual partners. He says ice reduced his ‘inhibitions’ and gave him ‘a lot more energy’ and a ‘sense of empowerment’. He also took GHB as ‘an expansion’ on ice as he says their
Conclusion
Where much alcohol and other drug research takes for granted the status of addiction as a pre-existing problem that precedes our actions, we have sought to draw attention to the ways in which addiction takes shape through our attempts to understand it and, importantly for our purposes, through the process of narrating lived experiences. In developing the personal narratives for publication on a website, our aim has been to give voice to a diverse range of experiences that exceed the
Acknowledgments
The research reported in this paper was conducted in the Social Studies of Addiction Concepts (SSAC) Research Program, based in the National Drug Research Institute, Faculty of Health Sciences, Curtin University, in collaboration with Healthtalk Australia, Monash University, the University of New South Wales’ Centre for Social Research in Health and the Hunter New England Local Health District. The research was funded by the Australian Research Council (Discovery Project DP140100996). Suzanne
References (50)
- et al.
Enacting multiple methamphetamines: The ontological politics of public discourse and consumer accounts of a drug and its effects
International Journal of Drug Policy
(2013) The chronotope of the queue: Methadone maintenance treatment and the production of time, space and subjects
International Journal of Drug Policy
(2006)- et al.
Addicts’ narratives of recovery from drug use: Constructing a non-addict identity
Social Science & Medicine
(2000) Erasing pleasure from public discourse on illicit drugs: On the creation and reproduction of an absence
International Journal of Drug Policy
(2008)- et al.
Are drug treatment services only for ‘thieving junkie scumbags’? Drug users and the management of stigmatised identities
Social Science & Medicine
(2008) Socio-spatial stigmatization and the contested space of addiction treatment: Remapping strategies of opposition to the disorder of drugs?
Social Science & Medicine
(2010)- et al.
Trauma, damage and pleasure: Rethinking problematic drug use
International Journal of Drug Policy
(2008) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
(2013)Stories of change in drug treatment: a narrative analysis of ‘whats’ and ‘hows’ in institutional storytelling
Sociology of Health and Illness
(2015)Alcohol and other drug treatment services in Australia 2012–2013. Drug treatment series 24, Cat. no. HSE 150
(2014)
What can we say about substance use? Dominant discourses and narratives emergent from Australian media
Addiction Research & Theory
Scripting addiction: The politics of therapeutic talk and American sobriety
Governing drug use otherwise: For an ethics of care
Journal of Sociology
Making addictions in standardised screening and diagnostic tools
Health Sociology Review
Ideological tropes of contemporary addiction narratives. Challenging addiction in Canadian literature and classrooms
Syringes, metonymy, global fear and news
Framing drug use: Bodies, space, economy and crime
Substance and substitution: Methadone subjects in liberal societies
The drug effect: Constructing drugs and addiction
Habits: Remaking addiction
Second opinion: An introduction to health sociology
Researcher’s handbook for producing HealthTalkOnline and YouthHealthTalk websites
Health Experiences Research Group
Public and private practices: Addiction autobiography and its contradictions
Contemporary Drug Problems
What’s wrong with addiction?
Addiction and dependence: Making realities in the DSM
Addiction
After method: Mess in social science research
Cited by (40)
From prescribing dilemma to knowledge in practice: The ontological politics of benzodiazepines and Z-drugs
2023, Social Science and MedicineStaying with the silence: Silence as affording care in online alcohol and other drug counselling
2023, International Journal of Drug PolicyAging with drug use: Theorizing intersectionally with material gerontology and critical drug studies
2022, Journal of Aging StudiesCitation Excerpt :However, current drug policies do not adequately reflect the needs and vulnerabilities of aging populations with chronic conditions such as habitual drug use (Beynon et al., 2009; Beynon, McVeigh, & Roe, 2007; Crome & Crome, 2005; Roitto et al., 2019; Wu & Blazer, 2011). Within the scope of this article and with the aim of avoiding stigmatizing terminology (e.g. addiction, abuse or disorder), the term habitual drug use is used to mean extra-medical or other than medically prescribed use of licit or illicit drugs on a regular basis or as a daily lifestyle (see Fraser, Moore, & Keane, 2014; Pienaar & Dilkes-Frayne, 2017). Although the concern around habitual drug use among older adults has become evident only recently (UNODC, 2018), it is unsurprising that until the turn of the century, studying drug use among older adults was not a prominent research interest within social sciences, even gerontology itself.
Exploring the role of trauma in underpinning sexualised drug use (‘chemsex’) among gay, bisexual and other men who have sex with men in Singapore
2021, International Journal of Drug PolicyCitation Excerpt :In light of the scholarship that emphasises the role of SDU in underpinning risks of HIV and other STI acquisition, as well as that which critiques such deterministic approaches to investigating SDU, the present manuscript reports and discusses such dynamics among a sample comprising a majority of substance use treatment-experienced GBMSM, which narrows the scope of our findings, given that biographies of ‘addiction’ may tend to focus on ‘ruin-redemption’ accounts of individuals. These ‘ruin-redemption’ narratives often reflect stereotypical and pathological narratives of substance use in which drug use is associated with misery and pain, and abstinence with redemption and recovery (Pienaar & Dilkes-Frayne, 2017). Our study broadly investigated life histories of substance use and incarceration among a sample comprising a majority of substance use treatment-experienced GBMSM in Singapore to gain a better understanding of the social and structural factors surrounding SDU.
“Undisciplined” drinking, multi-sectoralism and political power: Examining problematisations in the Botswana alcohol policy
2021, International Journal of Drug PolicyCitation Excerpt :The use of binaries and dualisms in this way is troublesome mainly because neither concepts are singular (Moore, Pienaar, Dilkes-Frayne, & Fraser, 2017). Similar to existing research in drug studies (Manton & Moore, 2016; Pienaar & Dilkes-Frayne, 2017), this binary does not account for the everyday experiences of alcohol use in Botswana. It neither explains when drinkers become ‘undisciplined’ nor when they are ‘disciplined’.